The original novel is often credited with deeper character work and more convincing motivations.
"Red Joan is unlikely to appeal to younger audiences... but it will win fans because there is much to admire: The solid acting... [and] evocative cinematography." [18] Red Joan
Critics often praise the performances but find the pacing and tone to be somewhat standard for a period drama. The original novel is often credited with deeper
"The characters are vividly realized, and their manipulation of the innocent Joan into traitorous actions is built up carefully and made very believable." [24] Red Joan