: The pilot is often described as "scatterbrained" and "heavy-handed," with some critics at Rotten Tomatoes noting that the "choppy pacing" and "slow burn" may test viewers' patience.
: Reviewers at IGN noted that the series trades the "steaminess" of the 1980 film for a darker, more dreary "soapy redemption story" focused on past trauma and a central murder mystery. American.Gigolo.S01E01.WEBRip.x264-ION10
: Critics agree that Jon Bernthal is the show's strongest asset, bringing a muted magnetism and vulnerability to the role of Julian Kaye that differentiates him from Richard Gere's original version. : The pilot is often described as "scatterbrained"
: Rosie O’Donnell’s performance as Detective Joan Sunday is highlighted as a source of much-needed "levity and energy". Episode Highlights & Score "American Gigolo" Pilot (TV Episode 2022) - IMDb : Rosie O’Donnell’s performance as Detective Joan Sunday